Two independent studies show that while excessive Facebook usage makes us unhealthy, WhatsApp is seen as the perfect tool for students to be more open outside the hierarchical divisions in a school.
People who check their Facebook profile all the time are likely to be more sad and unhealthy than those who use it sporadically, a new study has revealed.
Researchers from Yale University and the University of California, San Diego (UCSD), studied the pattern of Facebook use and mental health of 5,208 volunteers between 2013 and 2015 for the study. The findings showed that increased use of Facebook was closely linked to “compromised social, physical and psychological health”, Metro.co.uk reported on Sunday.
It also revealed that if users were updating their profiles or liking posts more than average, they were more likely to have mental health issues.
The report appeared in the American Journal of Epidemiology and was led by UCSD’s Assistant Professor of Public Health Holly Shakya and Yale’s Nicholas Christakis, who is Director of the University’s Human Nature Lab.
Study on WhatsApp’s positive influence
Mobile messaging service WhatsApp helps teenagers communicate better and to openly express themselves with their peers than in their classrooms, a study has claimed.
The findings showed that WhatsApp groups allow teenagers to express themselves in ways that they cannot at school, helping them develop closer and more open relationships with their classmates.
“The group chats are based on trust among the members of the group, and this enhances the possibility to be in contact,” Arie Kizel from University of Haifa in Israel, was quoted as saying to nocamels.com — an Israeli Innovation news website on Sunday.
“The discussions on WhatsApp enable the development of a social environment that is warm and human,” Kizel added.
In order to examine the way teenagers experience this virtual space, the team included two groups of eight youths aged 16-17 and two groups of eight youths aged 14-15.
The teengers perceived the WhatsApp group as a space that breaks down the hierarchical division created at school. One student described WhatsApp as “a place where there is respect for language and where all those involved share common terms and signs.”
“On WhatsApp, I usually feel that I am not being judged, particularly because there isn’t any eye contact or physical contact, only words and signs. So I feel more intimacy and security,” explained another participant.
The school domain often divides the class into fixed groups and friendships, created on the basis of socioeconomic status, common activities or study tracks, and so forth.
However, the WhatsApp groups break down these divisions and make the class a single, homogeneous group.
“In the WhatsApp group, everyone can talk to everyone else. WhatsApp breaks down the walls we put up between us in class. The WhatsApp group is like a class team-building day,” one participant commented.